Money Talk with Carl Stuart

Money Talk with Carl Stuart > All Episodes

November 14, 2026

Real Estate Cycles, College Savings, and When Your Financial Advisor Fails You

By: Carl Stuart

Carl takes caller and text questions on residential real estate investment timelines, investment strategies for mid-term goals, college savings plans, and portfolio diversification.

The full transcript of this episode of Money Talk with Carl Stuart is available on the KUT & KUTX Studio website. The transcript is also available as subtitles or captions on some podcast apps.

KUT Announcer: Laurie Gallardo [00:00:02] This is Money Talk with Carl Stewart. Carl Stewart is an investment advisor representative of Stewart Investment Advisors. Call or text him with your questions at 512-921-5888. Now, here’s Carl.

Carl Stuart [00:00:21] Welcome to Money Talk, I’m Carl Stewart and you’re listening to the KUT News 90.5 and the Kut App. Money Talk is a broadcast about the role of financial and investment planning where you always determine our agenda by calling or texting 512-921-5888. If you are a regular listener, welcome back. If you’re a first time listener, stick around, I think you’ll enjoy the broadcast and become. Regular listener. I take today’s calls first and then today’s texts and then previous texts that I have not had the opportunity to answer. Great idea to call or text right at the top of the show giving me ample time to do my best to answer your question. The number again 512-921-5888. Here we go. Hi Carl, I recently bought a home and circumstances have changed to the point that I am not sure we will be staying in the area. Is there a standard number of years of formula with or without a realtor for example? Of course the housing market, before it is financially responsible to sell your house. I’ve always stayed in my homes for 10 years which does seem beneficial, but in this we may not have that luxury. What’s the break-even point? Three years, five years, thank you, Alyssa, you’re welcome Alyssa. Actually the asset class, residential real estate has cycles and so there’s no one period of time in my experience that I can answer your question to say if you keep the house for three years Alyssa or five years that’s likely to be a good thing Because what happens when you think about real estate? Uh… Is first of all like any other asset uh… The price is subject to supply and demand that’s number one uh… And two uh… Most people purchase homes and take a mortgage so real estates first and foremost subject to the demand for it relative to supply but the second thing is what’s the cost of the mortgage the higher the interest rates on mortgages the fewer people can qualify for a mortgage. So, when you think about that, and then you add the third thing, which is that real estate is an illiquid asset. What do I mean by that? Well, stocks and bonds and mutual funds and exchange-traded funds are what we call liquid assets because you can buy and sell them any business day. As you know, you cannot do that with your home. And secondly, you don’t know the value of your home on a day-to-day basis. Whereas you can look and see the value of your 401k or your individual or joint account. So real estate cycles frequently last for years, particularly if you’re in an area which has growth, meaning more people moving in, like we’ve experienced in central Texas. And yet, even in central, Texas, and for that matter, throughout Texas and the Southwest, we had a long period of time, years. When real estate prices declined. And ultimately, the federal government, when George H.W. Bush was president, had to come in with something called the Southwest Plan to basically close down most of our savings and loans and force them into other financial institutions. In commercial real estate, income-producing properties were particularly hard hit. But we had a period of time before that in the 1970s when we had sharp increases in inflation, caused most economists would say, by a combination of what was called the OPEC oil embargo and also the Great Society and the Vietnam War, all of those things came together to have a long period of rising inflation and that led to rising interest rates and that lead to fewer people being able to afford a home. Now what we’ve had is a huge increase in real estate prices, I’m talking residential per your question, that happened during the COVID pandemic. We saw prices for example in this market rise by as much as 40 percent and now we’re in a period of time where we’re seeing slow declines but declines nevertheless in central Austin and around Austin and the so-called metro area of where prices are declining. Slightly but they’re doing it month after month and so it’s there is no rule of thumb. I’ve mentioned this on previous broadcasts that people say their home is a great investment. I don’t frankly see it that way because I think you have to have a place to live but I will tell you this having growth is a key factor. So my hometown when I graduated from high school had 16,000 people today it has 9,000 I’m willing to bet there hasn’t been a real estate investment that’s been a good investment during what is almost a 50% decline in population. So it’s a long-winded answer, but I would say the good news is people are moving to Texas. You have that tailwind. Yes, mortgage rates are over 7%. That reduces the number of people who can qualify, and at least in the greater Austin market. We have vacancies in the apartment market. And so that’s also allowing people time to stay there. And so I think the outlook over the next year or so is probably that the value of your home, all things being equal, is probably gonna decline a little bit. So I think you’re just going to have to prioritize what’s most important to you in terms of where you wanna live or have to live. Versus thinking if I hold it for another year, somehow that’ll be a better deal for me. Thanks for the good question. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. We have all of our lines available and you’re welcome to call or text 512-921-5888. Here is another text. Hi Carl, my name is Ethan. I’m 27 and I’m investing a large portion of my income. Congratulations. When I have extra cash to invest, I’ve been struggling to figure out how to decide what to do with money I think I might need for big purchases in about five to 10 years, most notably a home. As of now, I’ve keeping an emergency fund and investing everything else in index funds for retirement so that I can maximize tax advantage space in my 401k and IRA. Is this generally the right approach or should I consider something more conservative in a brokerage account for these mid-term goals? Thank you. So there’s really a two-part answer to that. One is what’s the proper type of investment and the second is what is the proper domicile? Is it a 401k, IRA or what you call a broker-age account? That’s the easy one to answer. You’re young and as a result you would be Analyze sharply. If you took money out of your IRA or the 401k. So yes, you do want to have a brokerage account. I tend to think of capital or money in three different buckets. The first bucket is the money you have to live on, to buy gas, to buy groceries, that kind of thing. That’s in a checking account because you expect to spend the money so you’re not looking for a rate of return. The second bucket you’ve talked about is the short-term bucket. You called it an emergency fund, and that’s fine. And that’s a place where you would have money for the next one year or perhaps two or three years. And the choice of your investments there would be, depending on your risk tolerance, either a money market fund, probably a prime or a government money market with one of the large, if you’re a do-it-yourself investor, Vanguard or Fidelity or Schwab, they all have those kinds of money market funds. And then when you start talking about five to 10 years, you begin to think about taking on more risk. There’s a lot of data that indicate the longer that you’re invested, the less the risk is that you will have a negative return. That doesn’t mean it’s a guarantee. I just happened to mention the 1970s. Other than investing in gold or in things touched by energy and other commodities, it was a terrible decade for stocks and a terrible decades for bonds. But then the stock market, I’m talking the US equity market, bottomed in August of 1982 and peaked in March of 2000. That’s a long time. It then declined and then came back and has gone to new highs. And in between then, we had the global financial crisis, which was terrible and led to about a two-year bear market. So My sense is, if in the five to 10 year range, I’m pretty comfortable with you in index funds. I would say index funds in your brokerage account, preferably exchange traded funds, because they tend to be very tax efficient if they’re index funds or frankly, even if they are actively managed. And I would think you would want to have at least money in a total stock market index fund and then maybe a quarter of the money and international. Index fund. Thanks for the question. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. You can listen to Money talk right now and you can go at your convenience to kut.org slash money talk. You’ll see actually if you go to KUT.org you’ll see all the podcasts or you can go to your own wherever you like to get a podcast and download any and all of our broadcasts. 5-1-2 nine two one five eight eight eight here is a Call actually it’s a contact. It’s a text. I Carl any comments on Jensen Wang stepping down and prospects for Nvidia What’s your take? Thanks This is a big deal Barons today says that it’s the stock is a is a buy and That’s their opinion and that It’s underperformed a lot of the other so-called AI stocks, and that on price compared to its earnings, it’s very attractively priced. I think relative to other successful tech companies in the AI space, I agree that it is far less expensive. That’s good news. But we haven’t gotten through the proverbial woods. One of my favorite opinion writers as a woman named Peggy Noonan, who writes in today’s Wall Street Journal, that this has a potential to be a Watergate type situation. Now that’s a pretty significant comment, but as it goes with the federal government and the relationship between NVIDIA and top people in the administration, so this has not completely unwound yet, and I think as long, if this, if his resignation were the end of the story, I’d be more comfortable initiating a position in the stock if I were an individual stock buyer. But at least as of today, I don’t think we’ve seen all of the proverbial shoes dropping. And so I’d very cautious. It is a value today relative to its peers. But I think there could be more news out there that could be difficult for the stock. That’s my sense. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5. And the KUT app, call or text 512-921-5888. Here’s a text. Hi, Carl. My nephew has about $500,000 in a brokerage account and is planning on moving it into Fidelity and Charles Schwab, a half each. Is there a way to do that and minimize taxes he will pay? Thanks, Sarah. Well, it depends on if you say it’s in a brokery account. But what you don’t say is whether or not it’s invested. I’m going to assume it’s invest and I’m gonna assume that it’s investing in stocks or stock funds and he can transfer those funds to Fidelity or Schwab. But if he’s going to do that and then sell those securities to buy something at Fidelity and Schwab, there is no way to avoid that. If he’s held the securities for a year or longer, He’ll pay at a lower tax rate than his income tax rate there really is no other way to avoid that. That’s not a bad thing because if he’s making these decisions because he believes they’re best for him and he’s changing his investment strategy paying long-term capital gains tax is frankly as someone has said to me it’s hard to complain about taxes because you’re making money so I that’s how I would look at it. Thanks for your You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5. And on the KUT app. Call or text 512-921-5888. Here’s the text. Hi Carl, thanks so much for your show. You’re welcome. I believe I have heard you mention the possibility of including trend following funds in one’s portfolio. Would you recommend momentum exchange traded funds or trend following fund to diversify in either a tax advantage or taxable brokerage account? Since S&P 500 funds are about 40% invested in their top 10 largest stocks, what are our ways of diversifying through ETFs without paying large management fees? Okay. So you are an experienced investor. That is a sophisticated question. The thing about trend following as a strategy is that when there’s a sharp decline, in the stock market, in a sustained decline, not like the COVID decline, which only lasted 43 days from peak to trough to peak, okay? But like 2022, when the S&P 500 was down 19%, the NASDAQ was down 33%, and the Bloomberg Ag, which is the bond index, was down 13 to 14%, trend following funds were up 16, 17, 18%, because they were able to benefit from falling prices for bonds and falling prices for stocks. If you have something like what’s happened since the midterm elections, they’re not going to be beneficial because there’s been such a whipsaw. The market might be down two percent one day and up two percent the next day. But if you’re trying to find something that’s not correlated to equities in case there’s a substantial decline in the stock market over a longer period of time, I don’t think momentum funds are the place to be. I think trend following, and the reasons are number one, they can trade the four global asset classes of stocks, interest rates, commodities, and currencies. And so there can be trends away from the stock market, like a few years ago it was cocoa, that you don’t know about. There can be a strengthening of the dollar or a falling dollar versus the yen or pound sterling. So those are all pretty sophisticated things that you can do. Now. Is it, can you do that without paying large management fees? In my experience, the answer is no. These are not designed to be tax efficient. They don’t throw off much in the way of capital gains. I’ve never frankly seen one, but they can pay out dividends. And are they expensive? Yes, and it’s an expensive strategy. I’m not familiar with a lower expense ratio ETF that does this. I’m not saying it’s not there. But the ones I’ve seen tend to be in 40 open mutual funds, open and mutual funds I’m guessing, not being a securities lawyer, that that’s just the way they have to work trend following. So I like trend following for a sophisticated investor like you over momentum funds. Thanks for the text. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. We have all of our lines available. It’s a great time to call. I’m going to take a break. Call or text 512-921-5888. I’ll be back.

KUT Announcer: Mike Lee [00:17:43] If you’re a regular KUT listener, you know by now that members’ support makes everything we do possible, and you know all about becoming a sustaining member, but you might not know about another way to support the reliable news on KUT. If you have a donor-advised fund, you can support the station by recommending a grant to KUT! It’s a great way to show your support and to help ensure that KUT is your reliable news source, and it is way easier than it sounds. Find out more at KUT dot org slash legacy.

KUT Announcer: Laurie Gallardo [00:18:14] This is Money Talk with Carl Stewart. Call or text him with your questions at 512-921-5888. Now, here’s Carl.

Carl Stuart [00:18:28] Welcome back to Money Talk. I’m Carl Stewart and you’re listening to KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. When you have a financial or investment planning question, call or text 512-921-5888. This is a great text. I got this last Saturday but it was too late for me to have a chance to answer it. Hello Carl, my wife and I just had a baby today, all caps. Congratulations, baby’s now a week old. Could you tell me about college accounts available? This is from Robert. Congratulations, Robert, to you and to the baby’s mother. So. It’s a thoughtful question and I’m glad you’re thinking about it this early because what that means is you have a lot better chance of accomplishing your objectives because you have the magic of compounding over the next 18 years or so. I think a thoughtful conversation that most people don’t have in my experience is for you and your wife to decide how much of the college education are we going to pay for. There’s no right answer. But what I have seen is a 17-year-old is starting to look at colleges and universities while she’s entering her senior year in high school and discovers that there’s no money available. And that obviously makes a difference on which school she can select and how much debt she has to take. So thinking forward and saying, we’re going to, I’m just gonna use some examples. We’re going to be willing to pay for any in-state public university, college or university, full stop, so that if our child wants to go out of state or wants to stay in state but go to a private college, we’re not going to pay the whole works. There are people who say, look, I worked my way through college, were going to have our child subject to the same conditions, we are not going help. And then there are people who say, look, we think it’s such a great investment, we’re fortunate enough to have good income and assets, we’re gonna fund it. So that’s a really, really important decision. And I would say it’s something that I would encourage you now, encourage you to discuss. Now the question is, should you do this in a custodial account, a 529 college savings account, or just on your own? Probably in my view, the least attractive is the custodial account. Because while you’re the custodean, the assets belong to the child. And when the child is 21, it’s his or hers. There’s nothing you can do about it. And I don’t know about you, but let me just say I did not make the best decisions when I was 21. So if your child’s a male, then you’re really in trouble. Cause our brains don’t mature until who knows 45 or 46 years old. You don’t want that child have access to the capital. And during those first 21 years, you’re gonna pay taxes on the dividends, interest and capital gains anyway. So now the question is a 529 college savings plan or simply doing it on your own. The benefit of the college savings plans is that you don’t pay any taxes on any dividends, interest or realized capital gains. And since its inception, there’s been a much greater broadening of the purposes. So you can take the money out for an independent middle school if you want, or for a long list of other educational expenditures. And even you can change the beneficiaries. So if you subsequently have another child and the first child is out of college and the money is still there, you can transfer it to the younger child. So those are all the benefits. Now there are two or three drawbacks that early on when these came out, I was just simply unaware of. And that is, number one, and I actually saw this recently, a person ended up with too much money. The child had graduated, there was no one else that they had that they wanted to pay for college, and they were going to be subject to some penalties taking the money out. So that’s something, believe it or not, that can actually happen. The second thing is… Uh, say college savings plans are sponsored by states. Now you don’t have to worry about state income tax. If you live in Texas, if you move to some state that has income tax over the years, you could have a tax liability when you take the money out, but you’ve got to take, use the menu that’s that, that, the state has, uh, you can’t go to a Chinese food restaurant and order Mexican food. You’ve got go from the menu. That’s there. Personally, I don’t know if I’m going to be able to do that. I have come to be fond of doing it in a separate account, call it an education account that you and your wife own, where you have the maximum flexibility on your own or with your advisor to make the investments so you can have index funds, you can actively manage funds, you get to choose the asset you and or your advisor choose the asset allocation. And as the money grows, if you invest in tax efficient funds, of which there are many, you’ll have very little in the way of taxable income. And you have maximum flexibility to spend the money for whatever the heck you want to, to benefit your child. Or maybe not to benefit you child. I mean, two things can happen. They can go very badly for the child and you don’t want her to have the money. Or they can go really good for the kid and don’t need the money for college because she’s a fantastic volleyball player and gets a full right scholarship. So having that separate account. Where you’re putting money in, you can call it the education account, the Jane and John Doe education account and, and have full control of it. Frankly, I like that. And so, uh, it’s called it, the 5.9 plans are not bad, but I think this other third way may be also quite attractive. Thanks for the question. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. No calls today. The lines are available. Alissa would be happy to take your call, also I’d be happy to visit with you, but it’s just as well you can call or text 512-921-5888. Here, let me see, here comes a text. Hi, Carl. I have what is called a Roth 401k share account and a credit union. In Michigan, that I would love, okay, it was a period there. I have a Roth 401k share accounts. And a credit union in Michigan that I would like to move. It is only gaining 0.5%. Whoa, much less than even my high-yield interest savings account. The problem is, I’m not really sure what I can do with this account. And when I call the credit union, other than just leaving the money there, they don’t give me any idea of what I could do with it either. Have you ever heard of this type of account? No. If so, what are my options? Well, if it’s a Roth and a Roth 401k, A 401k is an employer sponsored plan and they would not have, to my knowledge, at a credit union. They would not be, frankly, meeting their fiduciary responsibilities. If you have a Roth, you can move that to any other custodian you want. You select a custodial, a mutual fund company, a broker dealer, an advisor, whatever you want. You can move that. And when it goes from one trustee to the other, there’s no taxes on that. If you have a 401k share account, of which I have not heard, if you are no longer an employee of that company in Michigan, you can take that money. And if the investment was not subject to tax, what we call pre-tax, you can do something called an IRA rollover, where you can choose a custodian and you can fill out the documents. And the custodian will go get the money from the credit union and you will have the full range of investments depending on what you choose either if you’re a do-it-yourselfer with Schwab Fidelity Vanguard or if you are not a do it yourself or with an investment advisor. So you do have maximum flexibility. Thanks for your text. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. Call or text 512. 921-5888. Here’s the text, 529s are now allowed to be rolled over to the Roth. Can you confirm? The answer is yes. They’re very specific, and I haven’t memorized them, very specific rules about how much can be rolled over, how long the 529 had quite some time to be invested. I suspect this is because when they did this statute, they didn’t want people using this. Is a backdoor way to get into Roth IRAs. So you need to do your homework, make sure that the 529 plan matches the situation and then you can roll it over. But it’s a modest amount of money. I think the number it sticks in my head is $35,000. And if that’s the case, and you were like the person I ran into who had six figures in the 5 29 plan, that was not gonna be very helpful for them. But the answer is yes, you can do that. Strict strict restrictions. Okay. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. Call or text 512-921-5888. Jay, you are on the air. How may I help?

Jay [00:28:39] Howdy, I’ve just moved back to Austin and now I’m now Starting a job where I’m making more than I’m used to making and I’m looking about I’m working for ways to invest that money because frankly, like I said, I’m a bit more than I’m use to and if I leave that just in my checking account, I probably gonna waste it. So yeah

Carl Stuart [00:29:02] It’s a great question. I’m glad you’re thinking this way. So what I would do because you’re making money periodically is I would set up an investment account, if you’re going to do this on your own, go with one of the big companies that have their own mutual funds like Charles Schwab or Fidelity, or Vanguard, or pick an advisor. But what you want to do is you open an account in your name and you Think that account. To your checking or savings account, and then you denote an amount of money and the period every month, for example, and whether it’s $500 or $1,000 or whatever it is, and they will automatically move it over to that account. And you’re still in control if you want to increase the size of it or you want to decrease it or if you wanna stop it. So there’s not, you’re not making any longterm commitment. And then you want to invest in something that’s tax efficient and also is broadly diversified. My favorite are called exchange traded funds. When you have enough money, I would have two. I’d start with one called a total stock market. And then when I had enough money to add, I’d add something called a Total International Market. And my objective would be to have about three quarters in the total stock markets and about a quarter from the International. And what you’re going to be taking advantage of, Jay, is something called dollar cost averaging, because these funds are going to go up in value over time. And periodically they’re going go down over time based on history. I’m not making a prediction. They’re going, to go higher, certainly higher than sitting in the bank. But by doing what I just said, let’s suppose you started this in 2022 when the global stock market declined, every month you were buying more shares at lower prices. And then when the stock market came back very sharply in the next four years, you had lower cost basis. So if you start doing that now, you retain total control, you can do this so it doesn’t have a negative impact on your tax situation, and you’re building a pillar separate from your career, that over time will be a very good thing to do, in my view, Jay.

Jay [00:31:20] All right, thank you.

Carl Stuart [00:31:22] You bet, thanks for calling. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. Call or text 512-921-5888. Mike, you are on the air, how may I help?

Mike [00:31:41] I’m a member of university federal credit union and I hear that university is going to be taken over by Michigan State University credit union. And you know I don’t see where it’s been taken over and says it’s going to be under the Michigan charter. And you now I don’t see where benefits any of us in Austin, any of the members in being won by Michigan. And, you know, the other question is, I guess… That the member’s equity is about $900 per member. Are they just handing it over to them? I’d like to hear your thoughts.

Carl Stuart [00:32:19] Yeah, you bet. I think it depends on the nature of the transaction and I’m not a securities lawyer, but if it’s, if university credit is not getting any cash in the transaction, then you would not, in my view, be getting any cash. You would just have that equity account in the combined firm, and I don’t see that there’s any benefit. Additional benefit to you or any additional liability to you. We had back in the late or eighties and early nineties, university and lots of others, as I recall, went out of business and they were forced into other institutions that the federal government said you’re going to be now part of this savings and loan. Their deposits were safe, but it didn’t make them money there wasn’t something they could turn into cash so I in my view If you’re unhappy with it, I’d go someplace else, but I’d be very surprised if you get any, that you get a check in the mail. If you do, that’s great, but I haven’t seen that occur.

Mike [00:33:27] Yeah, and I you know and the check check is not the issue. It’s like I hate to see taking over

Carl Stuart [00:33:35] Of course you did. Yeah. Yeah

Mike [00:33:38] And looking at the reviews of that credit union, I find a lot of people at Yelp don’t like it.

Carl Stuart [00:33:48] Good reason, good reason to take your money up someplace else.

Mike [00:33:53] Yeah, I agree, and I don’t see what advantage there is at all.

Carl Stuart [00:33:57] There’s got to be some advantage to the people who run the credit union, but again, if it were a public company, you could figure out was it a stock-for-stock trade or was it a cash-in-stock deal or all cash, but when it’s this kind of situation, I just don’t know what the benefit is to you. Okay. Thank you very much. I appreciate your wisdom. You’re welcome. Thanks for calling. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5. And the KUT app. Call or text 512-921-5888. Ryan, you are on the air. How may I help?

Ryan [00:34:39] I got a quick question. I want to find out if you had any leads or information on a financial attorney that I could start a process following up from your previous caller there I did dollar cost average but the money ended up into a just a regular account. And my fiduciary who said he was my fiduciaries did not pay attention to it at all. The money accumulated over eight months. And instead of buying dollar cost average, let’s just say the mutual funds was at $33, they decided after they figured it out, they would just buy everything at $46. Whoa!

Ryan [00:35:30] And so I lost out on the difference there in which they said, well, this is the difference. Here you go. But my complaint is like, yeah, but that would have gained over that period of time. And then if there were dividends, I missed out on that. And in all this, I was dropped by the financial advisor and sent on my own.

Carl Stuart [00:35:55] So, so let me ask a question, uh, Ryan, was your relationship, business relationship with the advisor was, did you, was this discretionary where they would, they would decide how to invest the money or was it nondiscretionary where they needed your approval?

Ryan [00:36:13] They need my approval.

Carl Stuart [00:36:15] That’s a non-discretionary. I think you’re going to have a tougher time. I just think if it was discretionary and they let it sit in cash when it was your understanding with them that they were going to be investing, I think that you’ve got a better shot at some kind of recompense. The fact that it was non- discretionary, you can still talk to a lawyer, but I think gonna be it’s gonna be a big a big to get that accomplished. Obviously, I’m not a securities attorney. What I would do is I would use ChatGBT or Google to find the names of local securities lawyers. And then I’d start my process by calling them and setting up either a Zoom appointment or go in the office, explain your process, and see if they’re willing to take it on. Uh, it probably would require a substantial amount of money on your part. The loss that would be to justify paying the legal fees. But, uh, if it had been discretionary account where they were, they’re required to act in your best interest, they would have been held responsible for not investing it when you and they agreed to invest it. So that’s how I go, go about it.

Ryan [00:37:33] I might have that backwards then the way you explain it there. I might’ve misinterpreted that on my comments that I wanted it in a certain two mutual or certain mutual funds. Yeah. And they did not put it in that they, it went into an account.

Carl Stuart [00:37:53] Money market fund or a cash account or something like that. A money market funds. Yeah.

Ryan [00:37:57] And then after it was discovered, it was put into those two, but only discovered by me because there was a buildup of cash in those accounts.

Carl Stuart [00:38:05] Yeah, yeah, that’s a must. There’s clearly that’s a mistake. And I you have every right to seek to seek an attorney. That’s that’s mistake. And I pursue it. I agree with the thrust of your commentary. I pursue if I were in your shoes.

Ryan [00:38:21] And also the, is there a element there that I act of asking, are you my fiduciary? He said, yes. I said, well then how am I ending up in this? Yeah. Not the best interest for me. Yeah. Yeah.

Carl Stuart [00:38:34] If in fact he is, I’m going to get fancy here, if he’s an investment advisor representative of a registered investment advisor, he has fiduciary responsibility. That is correct. If he said he did have it, but he’s not what I just said, then he was mistaken to tell you that in the first place. So you’re going to have to take that kind of information when you seek an attorney to find out for sure.

Ryan [00:38:58] All right. Well, I appreciate your time.

Carl Stuart [00:39:01] Okay. Good luck. Thanks for calling. It’s time for me to take a break. It’s a great time for you to call or text 512-921-5888. Stick around for the rest of Money Talk.

Jimmy Maas [00:39:21] Money Talk airs every Saturday at five o’clock on KUT News 90.5 FM on the KUT app and at KUT.org. This podcast is produced by KUT and KUTX Studios as part of KUT Public Media, home of Austin’s NPR station and the Austin Music Experience. We are a nonprofit media organization. If you feel like this is something worth supporting, set an amount that’s right for you and make a donation at supportthispodcast.org

KUT Announcer: Laurie Gallardo [00:39:51] This is Money Talk with Carl Stewart. Call or text him with your questions at 512-921-5888. Now, here’s Carl.

Carl Stuart [00:40:05] Welcome back. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. If you’d like to listen to previous broadcasts, you can go to kut.org. You’ll see all the various shows there slash Money Talk. Listen to previous podcasts. You can also get those wherever you get your podcasts. This afternoon, this evening, whenever you’re listening, 512. That actually is not true because if you’re listening to the podcast, don’t call. The right now, the number to call or text is 512-921-5888. Let’s get this call. Jenny, you are on the air. How may I help?

Jenny [00:40:45] Hello. Yes, sir. I retired three years ago. I’m coming up on 68. And this is such a basic question that I’m embarrassed to ask it. But I have not touched my 401k since I left my employer. Yeah. And, you know, I’m thinking my goal is to put that off as long as possible. I had about a million dollars in it. And it has been in free fall for you know the last probably six months I guess you know and I just keep seeing the number shrink and shrink and shrink like you know fifty thousand dollars or so and my question is you know how does it work there was a point where it was well over a million fifteen thousand whatever you know is that by quite a bit and I thought oh now it’s the time let’s lock it in and let’s get the money but you know I’m still invested in bonds and a little bit of stock. And I didn’t think it would be very volatile.

Carl Stuart [00:41:48] Well, what, yeah. So what’s happened this year is that bonds are down now that it’s from January till now the index that follows bonds through yesterday’s down about one and a half percent, but that doesn’t mean, you know, that it couldn’t have gone down more than that stocks are up for the year now they’ve been down from their peak, but it sounds like what you’ve got is What you think you have, you have probably stock mutual funds and bond mutual funds. And I would say if I were in your shoes and I, and I was going to not touch the money for three years, then once I was comfortable that I had the right mix between stocks and bonds, I’d leave it alone because this happened four years ago in 2022 when you were still working. The stocks went down somewhere between 20 and 30%. Just think of that. And the bonds went down between 10 and 15%. But then you’ve had terrific returns in 23, 24, 25. And even this year on a year to date basis, the standard and poor 500 through yesterday is up about 11 and a half percent. So if I were gonna be cashing it in this, you know, next year, Would I make some changes in the portfolio? Yes, but if I had a three year horizon, I’d go see how I was invested. How much in stocks, how much in bonds and what kind of stock funds. And if you will do that and you wanna call back to Money Talk, say next Saturday and tell me what your asset allocation is, I’ll give you my views on if that’s okay or not, if you’d like to do that. You

Jenny [00:43:35] Okay, yeah, I’m fairly familiar with how it’s allocated, you know, but do you mean like drill down like the type of bonds and

Carl Stuart [00:43:43] No, well, that’s helpful. The name, you know, I’d be interested in how much is in domestic, how much in foreign, and what type of bond funds they are, because bonds can be short-term, intermediate-term long-term. They can be foreign. They can be domestic. They could be high-yield. They can be investment-grade. It’s complicated. So I can’t just give you a solid view with what we know this afternoon.

Jenny [00:44:06] Okay, got it. I understand. Yes, I’m hoping to wait several years so that gives me a horizon. I will take a look and call back. Thank you so much.

Carl Stuart [00:44:13] Okay, Jen, you bet. Thanks for calling. You’re listening to Money Talk on KUT News 90.5 and the KUT app. I do not make specific securities recommendations because I don’t know your full situation and because I don’t want to be taken out and shot.

This transcript was transcribed by AI, and lightly edited by a human. Accuracy may vary. This text may be revised in the future.


Episodes

November 14, 2026

Real Estate Cycles, College Savings, and When Your Financial Advisor Fails You

Carl takes caller and text questions on residential real estate investment timelines, investment strategies for mid-term goals, college savings plans, and portfolio diversification.

Listen

November 7, 2026

The Roth vs. Traditional Debate: What Actually Works for Your Retirement

Carl Stuart takes text and caller questions on low-cost index ETF’s, Roth vs traditional IRAs, and gold as a portfolio investment.

Listen

October 31, 2026

AI, Market Volatility & Your Portfolio: Navigating The Investment Landscape

Carl Stewart takes caller and text questions on investment strategy, diversifying away from concentrated stock positions and why broad index funds are safer than betting on individual companies, asset allocation, employer 401(k) matches, Roth IRA strategies, and the transformational potential of AI investments, and the importance of staying disciplined during market volatility.

Listen

October 24, 2026

Bonds Down, Stocks Up: Strategic Asset Allocation for Every Life Stage

Carl Stuart takes called and text questions on investment strategies for different life stages, tax-advantaged retirement accounts, and bond markets and interest rates.

Listen

October 17, 2026

Your $890K Inheritance: A Tax Strategy That Could Preserve More for Your Kid

Carl Stuart takes caller and text questions on the importance of tax-efficient strategies like the step-up in basis, dollar-cost averaging when investing lump sums, and maintaining a diversified portfolio across stocks, bonds, and alternative investments. He also addresses broader economic concerns about AI spending, market valuations, and the bifurcated economy affecting different income levels. **NOTE […]

Listen

October 10, 2026

Bonds, ETFs, and the 75-25 Rule: Building Wealth at Every Age

Carl Stuart takes caller and text questions on capital gains and tax implications.

Listen

October 3, 2026

From Stock Picking to Index Funds: A Beginner’s Guide to Diversified Investing

Carl Stuart and Jimmy Maas talk about the importance of owning diversified, and guides audience through low-cost index funds, ETFs or mutual funds.

Listen

September 26, 2026

Life Insurance, Annuities, and Retirement Investing: A Comprehensive Guide

Carl Stuart and Jimmy Maas discuss the different the different types and purposes of life insurance, fixed and variable annuities and their investment components, and retirement savings strategies and investment vehicles for catching up on retirement savings.

Listen